Content Corner: Primary Sources
In the continued pursuit of higher order thinking (and connected to my last post about political cartoons, since they fall under this category) we will be looking at using primary source documents. Similar to political cartoons, this allows students to step into the shoes of someone else and evaluate their perspective. A fair warning, teaching students to be effective readers of these documents can be difficult, especially for struggling learners, but I assure you it can be done.

Much of the reasoning for why to use primary sources was covered in my previous content corner on political cartoons, but in short these documents will foster critical thinking in students and give a deeper insight to comparing fact with opinion. Here's an example, when teaching students about the Black Death that ravaged Europe I supply them with the all important background information about the time period. Students are then encouraged to use this to inform their thinking when they read the document.
Link to the document: I'd recommend chunking this down for students. https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/source/decameronintro.asp
In this example, when reading this document they see some interesting points to note: the reason for the plague is believed to be supernatural, the sickness is believed to be airborne, and individuals have a variety of reactions to the disease with which my students thought to be logical reactions. This helped students to identify some of the major themes from the time period and the event: religion played a vital role in the world view of these people, their scientific knowledge was much more primitive then our own, and interestingly enough, people reacted to the fear in similar ways expected from people today during a fear of a new, powerful disease. Some primary sources allow us the beauty of bringing in the past and relating it to the current day, like the above example. This is not often easy but assist students who struggle to see the value of the learning at face value in seeing how these events can relate to them, even if it occurred over 2000 years ago on a distant continent.
For many students this learning exercise is difficult. For the struggling learner, I want to provide teachers with some ideas.
1) Start off small:
A primary source does not have to be a page-long document, it could be a quote or the caption to an antiquated image. This makes the main idea and focus of the subject much easier for students to grasp.
2) Chunk it down:
A strategy often used with struggling students, dividing up the reading into portions can help students not bock at the larger task at hand and help them digest the information at a comfortable pace.
3) Work in groups:
Cooperative learning is imperative when pursuing higher-order thinking. Break students up into groups and have them read and discuss a document and come out with ideas they agree and disagree about. Great for powerful conversation.
This video introduction can be helpful to help students understand the WHY in teaching.
Check out this website on the PAPER method of reading articles. This is great practice for students looking to take honors or AP courses.


Comments