top of page

Limitations and Reflections

Writer: grahamcrackerjp
grahamcrackerjp
May 4, 2021
2 min read

The research is not without its limitations, which need to be honestly addressed. This research was conducted during a global pandemic – the spring of 2021. Student participation in outside activities was not only more difficult to facilitate this year, but also lowered the number of students participating in extracurriculars. The esports program used for this study was founded in Spring of 2020, and the low number of student participants is indicative of those challenges. These challenges lead to a small sample size for the study, with fewer data points than expected for the final data collection.



The control group for the study was a mixture of students involved in a variety of programs, some athletic and other academic. While studies have already demonstrated that students involved in either of these types of activities provide similar scores in motivation and engagement, having a specific breakdown between athletic and academic activities may support greater validity in the research (Jordan 1999). Associated with this is that many students participate in an array of activities, which might support the more general approach of this study – every student who participated in this study has their own unique experiences with extra-curriculars.


The final and perhaps greatest issue is the Impact of Extracurriculars Survey. This survey was created by me, based on a broad collection of surveys used in previous research settings. While the created questions were based on previously used surveys in research, this survey has never been used outside of this research setting and the validity of this tool could use further exploration, specifically if certain questions effectively gauged student motivation, engagement, and self-efficacy as well as others.

Nonetheless, upon addressing these limitations there is a great value to this research. Very little has been written or researched about esports, let alone how it relates to high school students, and this work marks the beginning of a whole new topic in education. I can qualitatively say that many of the students who joined this program came from backgrounds that did not involve them in more traditional extracurricular settings. Students also experienced growth in communication and problem solving which was evident throughout the esports season. I hope to see continual growth for this esports program and with the expansion of more members and the addition of other games to provide a varied esports experience. Perhaps in time, this study could be carried out again, with a larger, more established program and a more refined research tool.



Works Cited:

Jordan, W. J. (1999). Black High School Students Participation in School-Sponsored Sports Activities: Effects on School Engagement and Achievement. The Journal of Negro Education, 68(1), 54. doi: 10.2307/2668209


 
 
 

2 Comments


Jordyn Beck
Jordyn Beck
May 05, 2021

Josh, you laid out your limitations well. I think Covid-19 has been the biggest limitation for all of us. Not only did the pandemic change the sample group size, but the pandemic also through many wrenches into the timing of things. For me, I had to push back some of my research due to quarantines and teacher vaccination days. Despite these challenges, it appears that you were able to successfully implement your research, and you produced great results.


I think your research is definitely cutting edge. Esports, if I'm correct, is fairly new, and there is not much research about this type of extracurricular and its affects on students. I hope your program continues to grow and that you find…

Like

Joshua DeSantis
Joshua DeSantis
May 04, 2021

You do a solid job of laying some of the initial limitations with your findings. Don't forget the issue we discussed during your check-ins... I think that any 'next-step' studies should also include a control group of students who do not participate in school extracurriculars. I would also suggest that you look at a broader spectrum of factors that contribute to 'school engagement' including attendance, graduation rates, etc. It would also be very interesting to disaggregate the data to determine if gamers' grade level / gender / GPA / etc. also see these benefits or if they see these benefits at different levels. Overall though, this was a sufficient summary of the limitations inherent in your study.

Like

2021: Joshua Graham

bottom of page